|  2023  | |
| hardback illustration | Manzi Jackson for Africa Risen by Sheree Renée Thomas, Oghenechovwe Donald Ekpeki & Zelda Knight, eds. (Tor) | 
| paperback/ebook cover illustration | Luisa Preissler for The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow by Rachel Aaron (self-publishesd) | 
| magazine cover | Tehani Farr for Eternus #1 Metal Variant Oct 2022 | 
| interior illustration | Omar Rayyan for Animal Farm by George Orwell (Suntup Editions) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Steady”, Serena Malyon | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Listener”, Ed Binkley | 
| three-dimensional art | “The Boatman”, Dug Stanant | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Gregory Manchess | 
| art director | Neil Clarke, for Clarkesworld | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Discover the Impossible”, Ryan Pancoast | 
| product illustration | “The Lighthouse”, Nico Delort | 
|  2021  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Corinne Reid for Encounters with the Imaginary Vol. 3 by Jeszika Le Vye & Kira Night, eds. (Boneshaker) | 
| cover illustration, paperback or e-book | Charles Urbach for Ghost Riders in the Sky by Timothy Zahn (Swallow's End) | 
| magazine illustration | Francesca Resta for Clarkesworld #169 | 
| interior illustration | Iris Compiet for The Dark Bestiary by Adam Cesare (Insight) | 
| color work, unpublished | “The Selkie”, Kai Carpenter | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Unmasked”, Ashley Hankins | 
| three-dimensional | “The Birdcage Bandit”, Lisa Sell | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Richard Corben | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Sublime Epiphany”, Lindsey Look | 
| product illustration | “A Clockwork Orange”, Wylie Beckert | 
|  2020  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Eric Wilkerson for Tristan Strong Punches a Hole in the Sky by Kwame Mbalia (Disney Hyperion) | 
| cover illustration, paperback or e-book | Amanda Makepeace for The Long List Anthology Volume 5 (Diabolical Plots) | 
| magazine illustration | Evan Cagle for Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Chosen Ones #1 | 
| interior illustration | John Picacio for Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo (Flatiron) | 
| color work, unpublished | “The Raven, the Wolf and the Maiden”, Debbit Hughes | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Gyhan akaii dannan Deli Iatt (She who sits at the end of the world upon a mountain of bones dreaming)”, Tehani Farr | 
| three-dimensional | “Selene”, Forest Rogers | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Syd Mead | 
| art director | Lauren Panepinto | 
| gaming-related illustration | “King By His Own Hand”, Charles Urbach | 
| product illustration | Olde Fae tuck box, Rachel Quinlan | 
|  2019  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Jon Foster for I Met a Traveller in an Antique Land by Connie Willis (Subterranean) | 
| cover illustration, paperback or e-book | Amanda Makepeace for Diabolical Plots: Year Three by David Steffen, ed. (Diabolical Plots) | 
| magazine illustration | Arthur Haas for Clarkesworld May 2018 | 
| interior illustration | Vanessa Lemen for The Left Hand of Darkness by Ursula K. Le Guin (Easton) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Harvest”, Melissa Gay | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Failure to Launch: Grounded”, Chris Wade | 
| three-dimensional | “Reflection”, Patrick Masson | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Diane Dillon | 
| art director | Neil Clarke | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Frantic Search”, Mitchell Malloy | 
| product illustration | “The Pirate Queen”, Charles Urbach | 
|  2018  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Marc Simonetti for The Sword of Shannara by Terry Brooks (Grim Oak) | 
| cover illustration, paperback or e-book | Jaime Jones for The Tiger's Daughter by K. Arsenault Rivera (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Ingrid Kallick for Cricket Jan 2017 | 
| interior illustration | Gregory Manchess for Above the Timberline by Gregory Manchess (Saga) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Not All Treasure Is Gold”, Charles Urbach | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Dragon Drum”, Ruth Sanderson | 
| three-dimensional | “Octopoid Descending”, Forest Rogers | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Alan Lee | 
| art director | Neil Clarke | 
| gaming-related illustration | Offering Sagaborn RPG Core Rule Book, Melissa Gay | 
| product illustration | “Stormy Serenade”, Annie Stegg Gerard | 
|  2017  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Tran Nguyen for Kushiel's Dart by Jacqueline Carey (Subterranean) | 
| cover illustration, paperback or e-book | Julie Dillon for Beyond the Stars: At Galaxy's Edge by Ellen Campbell, ed. (Astral) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Galen Dara for Uncanny May/Jun 2016 | 
| interior illustration | Greg Ruth for “Freedom Is Space for the Spirit” by Glen Hirshberg (Tor.com Apr 2016) | 
| color work, unpublished | “In a World of Her Own”, Michael Whelan | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “The Fall of Night”, Allen Williams | 
| three-dimensional | “La Belle Crustace”, Forest Rogers | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Hayao Miyazaki | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Die Young”, Ryan Yee | 
| product illustration | Donato Giancola, for Portal Promotional art for Illuxcon | 
|  2016  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Todd Lockwood for Voyage of the Basilisk by Marie Brennan (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Tyler Jacobson for Beyond the Pool of Stars by Howard Andrew Jones (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Tran Nguyen for Uncanny #4 May/Jun 2015 | 
| interior illustration | Peter Mohrbacher for Angelarium: Book of Emanations by Eli Minaya & Peter Mohrbacher (Magnetic) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Beren and Luthien in the Court of Thingal and Melian”, Donato Giancola | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Symbiosis”, Travis Lewis | 
| three-dimensional | “The Morrigan”, Forest Rogers | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Kinuko Y. Craft | 
| art director | Neil Clarke, for Clarkesworld | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Fruit of the First Tree”, Ryan Yee | 
| product illustration | “El Arbol”, John Picacio | 
|  2015  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Julie Dillon for Shadows Beneath: The Writing Excuses Anthology by Brandon Sanderson, ed. (Dragonsteel) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Raoul Vitale for Nebula Awards Showcase 2014 by Kij Johnson, ed. (Pyr) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Julie Dillon for Analog Apr 2014 | 
| interior illustration | Anna Balbusso & Elena Balbusso for “Ekaterina and the Firebird” by Abra Staffin-Wiebe (Tor.com Jan 2014) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Alegretto”, Michael C. Hayes | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Sphynx”, Allen Williams | 
| three-dimensional | “The Mudpuppy”, Dan Chudzinski | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | John Harris | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Pharika, God of Affliction”, Peter Mohrbacher | 
| product illustration | George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire 2015 calendar, Donato Giancola | 
|  2014  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Todd Lockwood for A Natural History of Dragons by Marie Brennan (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Kerem Beyit for The Scroll of Years by Chris Willrich (Pyr) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Dan Dos Santos for Fables #136 Dec 2013 | 
| interior illustration | Brian Kesinger for Walking Your Octopus (Baby Tattoo) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Huor and Hurin Approaching Gondolin”, Donato Giancola | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “The Descent of Persephone”, Ruth Sanderson | 
| three-dimensional | “Cecaelia, Queen of the Ocean”, Devon Dorrity | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Jim Burns | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming-related illustration | “The Last Stand of Thorin Oakenshield”, Lucas Graciano | 
| product illustration | “Jeannie's Kitten”, Julie Bell & Boris Vallejo | 
|  2013  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Todd Lockwood for The Wild Road by Jennifer Roberson (DAW) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | John Picacio for The Creative Fire by Brenda Cooper (Pyr) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Ken Barthelmey for Clarkesworld #74 Nov 2012 | 
| interior illustration | Sam Burley for “Brother. Prince. Snake” by Cecil Castellucci (Tor.com) | 
| color work, unpublished | “A Passion for the Future”, Julie Bell | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Last of His Kind”, Raoul Vitale | 
| three-dimensional | “Ramautar”, James Shoop | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Brom | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Ereshkigal, Death Mistress”, David Palumbo | 
| product illustration | John Picacio | 
|  2012  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Tom Kidd for Deathbird Stories by Harlan Ellison (Subterranean) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Matthew Stewart for The Cloud Roads by Martha Wells (Night Shade) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Lee Moyer for Weird Tales Win 2010/2011 | 
| interior illustration | Julie Dillon for “The Dala Horse” by Michael Swanwick (Tor.com) | 
| color work, unpublished | “The Dragon and the Nightingale”, Omar Rayyan | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “The Yeti”, Raoul Vitale | 
| three-dimensional | (tie) “Roboboke”, Vincent Villafranca | 
| three-dimensional | (tie) “Moonstruck”, Michael Parkes | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Moebius/Jean Giraud | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Distress”, Michael C. Hayes | 
| product illustration | George R.R. Martin: A Song of Ice and Fire, 2012 Calendar, John Picacio | 
|  2011  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Michael Whelan for The Way of Kings by Brandon Sanderson (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Jason Chan for Geist by Phillipa Ballantine (Ace) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Nick Greenwood for Intergalactic Medicine Show Jun 2010 | 
| interior illustration | Donato Giancola for Middle-Earth: Visions of a Modern Myth by Donato Giancola (Underwood) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Planetary Alignment”, Julie Dillon | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Triptych”, Ian Miller | 
| three-dimensional | “Eel Walker”, Mark Newman | 
| lifetime artistic achievement | Boris Vallejo | 
| art director | Jon Schindehette | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Amorphous Drake”, Lucas Graciano | 
| product illustration | Shadow Rising, Sam Weber | 
|  2010  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Matt Stewart for The Valley of Shadows by Brian Cullen (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Scott Altmann for The Mysterious Mr. Spines: Flight by Jason Lethcoe (Grosset & Dunlap) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | John Picacio for Asimov's Sep 2009 | 
| interior illustration | Gary Lippincott for “Come to the Fairies' Ball” by Jane Yolen (Come to the Fairies' Ball) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Unrequited”, Raoul Vitale | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Steampunk Wizard of Oz”, Justin Gerard | 
| three-dimensional | “The Switching Hour”, Vincent Villafranca | 
| artistic achievement | Greg Hildebrandt | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Silverwing”, Lucas Graciano | 
| product illustration | “Battle Under the Mountain”, Matthew Stewart | 
| contribution to ASFA | Ingrid Neilson, for work on the Chesley Awards for 20+ years | 
|  2009  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Donato Giancola for A Book of Wizards by Marvin Kaye, ed. (SFBC) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | John Picacio for Fast Forward 2 by Lou Anders, ed. (Pyr) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Matts Minnhagen for Clarkesworld Magazine Apr 2008 | 
| interior illustration | Donato Giancola for “The Wraith” by J. Robert Lennon (Playboy Nov 2008) | 
| color work, unpublished | “The Gift”, Simon Dominic | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Kraken”, Simon Dominic | 
| three-dimensional | “Otherworldly Procession”, Vincent Villafranca | 
| artistic achievement | Julie Bell | 
| art director | Lou Anders | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Stoic Angel”, Volkan Baga | 
| product illustration | “Hellboy 2”, Dan Dos Santos | 
|  2008  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Donato Giancola for The Outback Stars by Sandra McDonald (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Donato Giancola for Crystal Dragon by Sharon Lee & Steve Miller (Meisha Merlin) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Cory & Catska Ench for F&SF Mar 2007 | 
| interior illustration | James Gurney for Dinotopia: Journey to Chandara by James Gurney (Andrews McNeel) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Red Sonja”, Donato Giancola | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Season of Change”, Donato Giancola | 
| three-dimensional | “A Conscious Entity and Its Maker”, Vincent Villafranca | 
| artistic achievement | Michael Wm. Kaluta | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Vanguard: Saga of Heroes”, Donato Giancola | 
| product illustration | “War of Angels”, Todd Lockwood | 
|  2007  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Stephan Martiniere for River of Gods by Ian McDonald (Pyr) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Daniel Dos Santos for Moon Called by Patricia Briggs (Ace) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Renee LeCompte for Fantasy Magazine Summer 2006 | 
| interior illustration | Omar Rayyan for Cricket | 
| color work, unpublished | “Galadriel's Harp”, Stephen Hickman | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Red Sonya”, Donato Giancola | 
| three-dimensional | “Ice Dragon”, Laura Reynolds | 
| artistic achievement | John Jude Palencar | 
| art direction | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming-related illustration | Dragons of Faerun, Todd Lockwood | 
| product illustration | Eugenio Caballero & William Stout | 
|  2006  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Stephan Martiniere for Elantris by Brandon Sanderson (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Tom Kidd for The Enchanted Completed by Harry Turtledove, ed. (Baen) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Donato Giancola for Asimov's Sep 2005 | 
| interior illustration | Brom for The Plucker | 
| color work, unpublished | “Companions to the Moon”, Charles Vess | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Nightmare”, Paul Bielaczyc | 
| three-dimensional | “Sleeper Lost in Dreams”, James Christensen | 
| artistic achievement | John Picacio | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming related illustration | “Blazing Archon”, Gabor Szikszai & Zoltan Boros | 
| product illustration | Justin Sweet | 
| contribution to ASFA | Julie Faith Rigby | 
|  2005  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | (tie) Tony DiTerlizzi for The Wrath of Mulgarath: The Spiderwick Chronicles Book 5 by Holly Black & Tony DiTerlizzi (Simon & Schuster) | 
| cover illustration, hardcover | (tie) Rick Berry for Queen of the Amazons by Judith Tarr (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, hardcover | (tie) Donato Giancola for The Nameless Day by Sara Douglass (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | John Picacio for Her Smoke Rose Up Forever by James Tiptree, Jr. (Tachyon Publications) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Omar Rayyan for Spider Magazine Oct 2004 | 
| interior illustration | Charles Vess for Medicine Road by Charles de Lint (Subterranean Press) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Water Nymph”, Marc Fishman | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “The Halls of Valhalla”, Robert Elneskog | 
| three-dimensional | “AF-Z4 The Duke an' Blinky”, Lawrence Northey | 
| artistic achievement | Omar Rayyan | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming related illustration | Mark Zug for Monte Cook's Arcana Unearthed (Malhavoc Press) | 
| product illustration | “Celtic King”, Dean Morrissey | 
| contribution to ASFA | Kat Angeli | 
|  2004  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Donato Giancola for City by Clifford D. Simak (Science Fiction Book Club) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Todd Lockwood for Tangled Webs by Elaine Cunningham (Wizards of the Coast) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Bob Eggleton for F&SF Jul 2003 | 
| interior illustration | Todd Lockwood for “Crossing Into the Empire” by Robert Silverberg (Realms of Fantasy Jun 2003) | 
| color work, unpublished | “She”, Michael Whelan | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Autumn Faeries”, Gary Lippincott | 
| three-dimensional | “Jack”, Gary Lippincott | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming related illustration | Todd Lockwood for Draconomicon | 
| product illustration | “Anna of the Celts”, Dean Morrissey | 
| contribution to ASFA | Teresa Patterson | 
|  2003  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Todd Lockwood for The Thousand Orcs by R. A. Salvatore (Wizards of the Coast) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Tristan Elwell for Briar Rose by Jane Yolen (Tor/Starscape) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Todd Lockwood for Dragon Dec 2002 | 
| interior illustration | Scott Gustafson for Classic Fairy Tales by Scott Gustafson (Greenwich Workshop/Hallmark) | 
| color work, unpublished | “The Storm”, Richard Hescox | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “The Skimmer's Lagoon”, Maurizio Manzieri | 
| three-dimensional | “Con Jose Dragon”, Kim Graham | 
| artistic achievement | Tom Kidd | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming related illustration | “Spider Queen”, Todd Lockwood | 
| product illustration | “The Light Ship”, Dean Morrissey | 
| contribution to ASFA | Geoff Surrette, for ASFA webpage management | 
|  2002  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Donato Giancola for Ashling by Isobelle Carmody (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Donato Giancola for The Hobbit: An Illustrated Edition of the Fantasy Classic by J. R. R. Tolkien, Charles Dixon & Sean Deming, [[-1-, illustrated by David Wenzel, adapted by -2- with -3-]] (Del Rey) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | James C. Christensen for The Leading Edge #41 Apr 2001 | 
| interior illustration | Tom Kidd for The War of the Worlds by H. G. Wells (Books of Wonder) | 
| color work, unpublished | “The Snow Tree”, Anne Sudworth | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “The Faeries of Spellcaster”, Tom Kidd | 
| three-dimensional | “Hall of the Mountain King”, Johnna Klukas | 
| artistic achievement | Donato Giancola | 
| art director | Paul Barnett | 
| gaming related illustration | “Shivan Dragon”, Donato Giancola | 
| product illustration | “Die Walküre”, Kinuko Y. Craft | 
| contribution to ASFA | Geoff Surrette, for ASFA (Association of Science Fiction & Fantasy Artists) webpage redesign & management | 
|  2001  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | John Jude Palencar for Forests of the Heart by Charles de Lint (Tor) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Jean-Pierre Targete for Circle at Center by Douglas Niles (Ace) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Todd Lockwood for Dragon Jul 2000 | 
| interior illustration | Kinuko Y. Craft for Cinderella by Kinuko Y. Craft (North-South/SeaStar) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Reach”, Michael Whelan | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “A Wizard of Earthsea”, Drew Willis | 
| three-dimensional | “Millennium Angel” (resin), Sandra Lira | 
| artistic achievement | Frank Kelly Freas | 
| art director | Irene Gallo | 
| gaming related illustration | Crucible: Conquest of the Final Realm, Ian Miller | 
| product illustration | “Dracopaleontology”, Donato Giancola | 
| contribution to ASFA | Todd Lockwood, Jon Schindehette & Wizards of the Coast | 
| award of distinction | Estate of Chesley Bonestell | 
|  2000  | |
| cover illustration, hardback book | Michael Whelan for Otherland: Mountain of Black Glass by Tad Williams | 
| cover illustration, paperback book | John Jude Palencar for The Terrorists of Irustan by Louise Marley | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Bob Eggleton for F&SF Aug 1999 | 
| interior illustration | James Gurney for Dinotopia: First Flight by James Gurney | 
| color work, unpublished | “At the Entmoot” (first displayed in 1999), Stephen Hickman | 
| monochrome, unpublished | “Artemis”, Rick Berry | 
| three-dimensional | “From the Astrologer's Anteroom” (furniture grouping), Johnna Klukas | 
| artistic achievement | Stephen Hickman | 
| art direction | Ron Spears | 
| gaming-related illustration | “Warriors of Heaven and Guide to Hell” (two-sided Duelist Insert Poster), Brom | 
| product illustration | “Cleopatra” (plate art for the Bradford Exchange), Richard Bober | 
| contribution to ASFA | Wizards of the Coast | 
|  1999  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Kinuko Y. Craft for Song for the Basilisk by Patricia A. McKillip | 
| cover illustration, paperback | John Jude Palencar for Tales of the Cthulhu Mythos by Anonymous, ed. | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Bob Eggleton for F&SF May 1998 | 
| interior illustration | Brian Froud for Good Faeries/Bad Faeries by Brian Froud & Terri Windling | 
| color work, unpublished | “Salvation” (oil), Marc Fishman | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Bottom & Titania” (black chalk), Beryl Bush | 
| three-dimensional | “Short Trip to October” (mixed media), Lisa Snellings | 
| artistic achievement | Bob Eggleton | 
| art director | Arnie Fenner & Cathy Fenner | 
| gaming-related illustration | “DragonLance Classics 15th Annual Game Module”, Todd Lockwood | 
| product illustration | “Archangel” (MagicTM cards package art), Donato Giancola | 
| contribution to ASFA | Jeff Watson, for creation & maintenance of the ASFA (Association of Science Fiction & Fantasy Artists) website | 
|  1998  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Bob Eggleton for The Howling Stones by Alan Dean Foster | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Michael Dashow for The Rhinoceros Who Quoted Nietzsche and other odd acquaintances by Peter S. Beagle | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Todd Lockwood for Dragon Aug 1997 | 
| interior illustration | Alan Lee for The Hobbit by J. R. R. Tolkien | 
| color work, unpublished | “The Astronomer Prince”, Stephen Hickman | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Silently Moving People”, Joy Marie Ledet | 
| three-dimensional | “Witchblade” (coldcast porcelain), Clayburn Moore | 
| artistic achievement | Vincent Di Fate | 
| art director | Jamie Warren Youll | 
| contribution to ASFA | Janny Wurts | 
|  1997  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Michael Whelan for The Golden Key by Melanie Rawn, Jennifer Roberson & Kate Elliott | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Donato Giancola for Eggheads by Emily Devenport | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Bob Eggleton for F&SF May 1996 | 
| interior illustration | Todd Lockwood for “Death Loves Me” by Tanith Lee (Realms of Fantasy Aug 1996) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Sinja's World”, Rob Alexander | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Waiting for Antony”, Davette Shands | 
| three-dimensional | “Princess” (bronze), Clayburn Moore & Frank Frazetta | 
| artistic achievement | Don Maitz | 
| art director | Jamie Warren Youll | 
| contributions to ASFA | Don Maitz | 
|  1996  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Tom Kidd for Kingdoms of the Night by Chris Bunch & Allan Cole | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Don Maitz for A Farce to Be Reckoned With by Roger Zelazny & Robert Sheckley | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Bob Eggleton for Analog Jan 1995 | 
| interior illustration | James Gurney for Dinotopia, the World Beneath by James Gurney | 
| color work, unpublished | “The Archers”, Stephen Hickman | 
| monochrome, unpublished | “Cerebus”, Todd Lockwood | 
| three-dimensional | “Wonderland”, Barclay Shaw | 
| artistic achievement | Thomas Canty | 
| art director | Jamie Warren Youll | 
| contribution to ASFA | Ingrid Neilson | 
|  1995  | |
| cover illustration, hardcover | Janny Wurts for The Curse of the Mistwraith by Janny Wurts (HarperCollins UK) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Alan M. Clark for Geckos by Carrie Richerson (Roadkill Press) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | (tie) Bob Eggleton for Asimov's Aug 1994 | 
| cover illustration, magazine | (tie) Wojtek Siudmak for Analog Dec 1994 | 
| interior illustration | Brian Froud for Lady Cottington's Pressed Fairy Book by Terry Jones & Brian Froud | 
| color work, unpublished | “The Pain Doctors of Suture Self General”, Alan M. Clark | 
| monochrome work, unpublished | “Promise”, Carl Lundgren | 
| three-dimensional | “Pitt”, Clayburn Moore | 
| artistic achievement | Frank Frazetta | 
| art director | Cathy Burnett & Arnie Fenner | 
| contribution to ASFA | David Lee Pancake | 
|  1994  | |
| hardback cover | Tom Kidd for The Far Kingdoms by Allan Cole & Chris Bunch (Ballantine Del Rey) | 
| paperback cover | Bob Eggleton for Dragans by Jack Dann & Gardner Dozois, eds. (Ace) | 
| magazine cover | Wojtek Siudmak for Asimov's Dec 1993 | 
| interior art | Alan M. Clark for “The Toad of Heaven” by Robert Reed (Asimov's Jun 1993) | 
| color art, unpublished | “Garden of Hope”, James Gurney | 
| monochrome art, unpublished | “Impudence”, Carl Lundgren | 
| three-dimensional | “Flying Pegasus and Rider”, Jennifer Weyland | 
| artistic achievement | Frank Kelly Freas | 
| art director | Jamie Warren Youll | 
| contribution to ASFA | (tie) Teresa Patterson, and Pegasus Management Crew | 
| contribution to ASFA | (tie) David Lee Pancake | 
|  1993  | |
| hardback cover | Don Maitz for Magician by Raymond E. Feist (Doubleday) | 
| paperback cover | David Cherry for Sword and Sorceress IX by Marion Zimmer Bradley, ed. (DAW) | 
| magazine cover | Michael Whelan for Asimov's Nov 1992 | 
| interior art | Alan M. Clark for “Poles Apart” by G. David Nordley (Analog mid-Dec 1992) | 
| color art, unpublished | “The Wizard of Owls”, Janny Wurts | 
| monochrome art, unpublished | “Tag, You're It”, David Cherry | 
| three-dimensional | “Reflection” (bronze), Gary Persello | 
| artistic achievement | James Gurney | 
| art director | Jamie Warren Youll | 
| contribution to ASFA | Ingrid Neilson | 
|  1992  | |
| cover illustration, hardback | Michael Whelan for The Summer Queen by Joan D. Vinge (Warner Questar) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | David Cherry for Sword and Sorceress VIII by Marion Zimmer Bradley, ed. (DAW) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | David Mattingly for Amazing Stories Sep 1991 | 
| interior art | Bob Walters for “It Grows on You” by Stephen King (Weird Tales Summer 1991) | 
| color art, unpublished | “Filia Mea”, David Cherry | 
| monochrome, unpublished | Michael Whelan, for study for All the Weyrs of Pern | 
| three-dimensional | “Celestial Jade”, Clayburn Moore | 
| artistic achievement | James Gurney | 
| art director | Betsy Wollheim & Sheila Gilbert | 
| contribution to ASFA | (tie) Richard Kelly | 
| contribution to ASFA | (tie) Jan Sherrell Gephardt | 
|  1991  | |
| cover illustration, hardback book | Keith Parkinson for Chernovog by C. J. Cherryh (DAW) | 
| cover illustration, paperback book | (tie) Michael Whelan for The Madness Season by C. S. Friedman (DAW) | 
| cover illustration, paperback book | (tie) Don Maitz for Magic Casement by Dave Duncan (Ballantine Del Rey) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Bob Eggleton for Aboriginal SF Jan 1990 | 
| interior illustration | Val Lakey Lindahn for “The Flowers, the Birds, the Leaves, the Bees” by L. A. Taylor (Analog Jun 1990) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Charting the Skies”, Dean Morrissey | 
| three-dimensional | “The Fishwalker” (bronze), James C. Christensen | 
| artistic achievement | Michael Whelan | 
| art director | Don Munson | 
| contribution to ASFA | Erin McKee & Bettyann Guarino | 
|  1990  | |
| cover illustration, hardback | Keith Parkinson for Rusalka by C. J. Cherryh (Ballantine Del Rey) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Stephen Hickman for Gryphon by Crawford Killian (Ballantine) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Frank Kelly Freas & Laura Brodian Kelly-Freas for Marion Zimmer Bradley's Fantasy Magazine Autumn 1989 | 
| interior illustration | Todd Cameron Hamilton for Dragonlover's Guide to Pern by Jody Lynn Nye & Anne McCaffrey (Ballantine Del Rey) | 
| color work, unpublished | “Winsor McCay City”, Tom Kidd | 
| monochrome, unpublished | “The Guardian”, Ruth Thompson | 
| three-dimensional | “Wave Born”, Arlin Robins | 
| artistic achievement | Don Maitz | 
| art director | Betsy Wollheim & Sheila Gilbert | 
| contribution to ASFA | David A. Cherry | 
|  1989  | |
| cover illustration, hardback | Don Maitz for Cyteen by C. J. Cherryh (Warner) | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Jody Lee for The Oathbound by Mercedes Lackey (DAW) | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Bob Eggleton for Asimov's Jul 1988 | 
| interior illustration | Alan Lee for Merlin Dreams by Peter Dickinson (Gollancz) | 
| color work, unpublished | “The Waterfall City”, James Gurney | 
| monochrome, unpublished | “Mechanical Owl”, Brad Foster | 
| three-dimensional | “Metropolis”, John A. Morrison | 
| artistic achievement | Don Maitz, for First Maitz | 
| contribution to ASFA | David Cherry, ASFA President | 
|  1988  | |
| cover, hardcover | James Gurney for On Stranger Tides by Tim Powers (Ace) | 
| cover, paperback | Don Maitz for Wizard War by Hugh Cook (Popular Library Questar) | 
| cover, magazine | Terry Lee for Amazing Stories Jan 1988 | 
| interior illustration | Janet Aulisio for Amazing Stories May 1987 | 
| color, unpublished | “Conjure Maitz”, Don Maitz | 
| black and white, unpublished | “Queen of the Snows”, Dawn Wilson | 
| three-dimensional | “Hawk Mountain”, John Longendorfer | 
| artistic achievement | Frank Frazetta | 
| ASFA contributor | Matt Fertig | 
|  1987  | |
| cover illustration, hardback | David Cherry for Chanur's Homecoming by C. J. Cherryh | 
| cover illustration, paperback | Michael Whelan for The Cat Who Walked Through Walls by Robert A. Heinlein | 
| cover illustration, magazine | Bob Eggleton for Asimov's Jan 1987 | 
| interior illustration | (tie) Bob Walters for “Vacuum Flowers” by Michael Swanwick (Asimov's mid-Dec 1986, Jan,Feb 1987) | 
| interior illustration | (tie) Dell Harris for Analog | 
| color, non-published | (tie) David Cherry | 
| color, non-published | (tie) “Sentinels”, Michael Whelan | 
| three-dimensional | “Magic Mountain”, Butch & Susan Honeck | 
| artistic achievement | Alex Schomburg | 
| special award: ASFA contributor | Matt Fertig | 
|  1985  | |
| hardcover cover | Michael Whelan for The Integral Trees by Larry Niven (Ballantine Del Rey) | 
| paperback cover | Carl Lundgren for The Day of the Dissonance by Alan Dean Foster (Warner) | 
| magazine cover | Bob Walters for “Promises to Keep” by Jack McDevitt (Asimov's Dec 1984) | 
| interior illustration | Dell Harris for Analog Mar 1985 | 
| color work, unpublished | “Winter's King”, Dawn Wilson | 
| black and white, unpublished | “Can I Keep Him, Mom?”, Suzanna Griffin | 
| three-dimensional | “Merchant of Dreams”, Hap Henriksen | 
| artistic achievement | Carl Lundgren | 
| special award: ASFA contributor | Michelle Lundgren |