|  2008  | |
| Living Legend | Peter Straub | 
| novel | The Terror, Dan Simmons | 
| long fiction | Softspoken, Lucius Shepard | 
| mid-length fiction | “Closet Dreams”, Lisa Tuttle | 
| short fiction | “Honey in the Wound”, Nancy Etchemendy | 
| illustrated narrative | The Nightmare Factory, Thomas Ligotti | 
| collection | Dagger Key and Other Stories, Lucius Shepard | 
| anthology | Inferno, Ellen Datlow, ed. | 
| nonfiction | Mario Bava: All the Colors of Dark, Tim Lucas | 
| periodical | Postscripts | 
| art | Elizabeth McGrath, for "The Incurable Disorder", Billy Shire Fine Arts, December 2007 | 
|  2007  | |
| Living Legend | Ramsey Campbell | 
| novel | The Unblemished, Conrad Williams | 
| long fiction | Dark Harvest, Norman Partridge | 
| mid-length fiction | “The Old North Road”, Paul Finch | 
| short fiction | “The Box”, Stephen Gallagher | 
| illustrated narrative | A.L.I.E.E.N., Lewis Trondheim | 
| collection | (tie) American Morons, Glen Hirshberg | 
| collection | (tie) Basic Black: Tales of Appropriate Fear, Terry Dowling | 
| anthology | Joe R. Lansdale's Lords of the Razor, Bill Sheehan & Bill Schafer, eds. | 
| nonfiction | Icons of Horror and the Supernatural: An Encyclopedia of Our Worst Nightmares, S. T. Joshi, ed. | 
| periodical | Subterranean | 
| art | (tie) Cover Story: The Art of John Picacio, John Picacio | 
| art | (tie) “Exhibits from the Imaginary Museum”, Aeron Alfrey | 
|  2006  | |
| Living Legend | Chelsea Quinn Yarbro | 
| novel | Lunar Park, Bret Easton Ellis | 
| long fiction | “Kiss of the Mudman”, Gary Braunbeck | 
| mid-length fiction | “La Peau Verte”, Caitlín R. Kiernan | 
| short fiction | “There's a Hole in the City”, Richard Bowes | 
| illustrated narrative | Memories, Enki Bilal | 
| collection | 20th Century Ghosts, Joe Hill | 
| nonfiction | Supernatural Literature of the World: An Encyclopedia, S. T. Joshi & Stefan Dziemianowicz | 
| periodical | Postscripts | 
| art | Clive Barker, for Exhibition: Visions of Heaven and Hell (and Then Some), Bert Green Fine Art, Los Angeles, CA | 
|  2005  | |
| Living Legend | Gahan Wilson | 
| novel | The Overnight, Ramsey Campbell | 
| first novel | The Ghost Writer, John Harwood | 
| long fiction | Viator, Lucius Shepard | 
| mid-length fiction | “Flat Diane”, Daniel Abraham | 
| short fiction | “A Pace of Change”, Don Tumasonis | 
| illustrated narrative | The Bug Boy, Hideshi Hino | 
| collection | The Wavering Knife, Brian Evenson | 
| anthology | Acquainted with the Night, Barbara Roden & Christopher Roden, eds. | 
| nonfiction | A Serious Life, D. M. Mitchell | 
| periodical | The Third Alternative | 
| art | (tie) Rick Berry | 
| art | (tie) Darrel Anderson | 
| film | Shaun of the Dead | 
| television | Lost | 
|  2004  | |
| Living Legend | Stephen King | 
| Living Legend | Everett F. Bleiler | 
| novel | lost boy lost girl, Peter Straub | 
| first novel | Jinn, Matthew B. J. Delaney | 
| long fiction | Louisiana Breakdown, Lucius Shepard | 
| medium fiction | “Dancing Men”, Glen Hirshberg | 
| short fiction | “With Acknowledgments to Sun Tzu”, Brian Hodge | 
| illustrated narrative | The Goon #1-4, Eric Powell | 
| collection | (tie) The Two Sams: Ghost Stories, Glen Hirshberg | 
| collection | (tie) More Tomorrow & Other Stories, Michael Marshall Smith | 
| anthology | The Dark: New Ghost Stories, Ellen Datlow, ed. | 
| nonfiction | The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair That Changed America, Erik Larson | 
| periodical | All Hallows | 
| art | Caniglia | 
| film | Spider | 
| television | Carnivale | 
| Special Award | Jack Cady | 
|  2003  | |
| Living Legend | Charles L. Grant | 
| novel | A Winter Haunting, Dan Simmons | 
| first novel | A Scattering of Jades, Alexander C. Irvine | 
| long form | “My Work Is Not Yet Done”, Thomas Ligotti | 
| intermediate form | (tie) “Death and Suffrage”, Dale Bailey | 
| intermediate form | (tie) “Pavane for a Prince of the Air”, Elizabeth Hand | 
| short form | “Prospect Cards”, Don Tumasonis | 
| graphic narrative | Abarat, Clive Barker | 
| collection | Figures in Rain, Chet Williamson | 
| anthology | Dark Terrors 6, Stephen Jones & David Sutton, eds. | 
| nonfiction | Ramsey Campbell, Probably: Essays on Horror and Sundry Fantasies, Ramsey Campbell | 
| periodical | F&SF | 
| art | Jason Van Hollander | 
| film | Frailty | 
| television | Six Feet Under | 
|  2002  | |
| Living Legend | William F. Nolan | 
| novel | Threshold, Caitlín R. Kiernan | 
| first novel | Ordinary Horror, David Searcy | 
| long fiction | “Cleopatra Brimstone”, Elizabeth Hand | 
| short fiction | “Onion”, Caitlín R. Kiernan | 
| illustrated narrative | Just a Pilgrim (5-issue miniseries), Garth Ennis & Carlos Ezquerra | 
| collection | Through Shattered Glass, David B. Silva | 
| anthology | Night Visions 10, Richard Chizmar, ed. | 
| nonfiction | Wild Hairs, David J. Schow | 
| publication | The Spook | 
| artist | John Picacio | 
| film | Ginger Snaps | 
| television | no award | 
|  2001  | |
| Living Legend | Alice Cooper | 
| novel | Declare, Tim Powers | 
| first novel | Adam's Fall, Sean Desmond | 
| long story | The Man on the Ceiling, Steve Rasnic Tem & Melanie Tem | 
| short story | “The Rag-and-Bone Men”, Steven Duffy | 
| illustrated narrative | I Feel Sick #1-2 (2-part series), Jhonen Vasquez | 
| collection | (tie) City Fishing, Steve Rasnic Tem | 
| collection | (tie) Ghost Music and Other Tales, Thomas Tessier | 
| anthology | October Dreams: A Celebration of Halloween, Richard Chizmar & Robert Morrish, eds. | 
| nonfiction | At the Foot of the Story Tree: An Inquiry into the Fiction of Peter Straub, Bill Sheehan | 
| publication | Horror Garage | 
| artist | Joel-Peter Witkin | 
| film | American Psycho | 
| television | Angel | 
|  2000  | |
| Living Legend | Richard Matheson | 
| novel | A Prayer for the Dying, Stewart O'Nan | 
| first novel | The Divinity Student, Michael Cisco | 
| long fiction | “Crocodile Rock”, Lucius Shepard | 
| short fiction | “The Emperor's Old Bones”, Gemma Files | 
| graphic story/illustrated narrative | Flinch #1-7, Axel Alonso & Joan Hilty, eds. | 
| collection | The Nightmare Chronicles, Douglas Clegg | 
| anthology | Subterranean Gallery, Richard Chizmar & William K. Schafer, eds. | 
| nonfiction | Fantasy and Horror: A Critical and Historical Guide to Literature, Illustration, Film, TV, Radio, and the Internet, Neil Barron, ed. | 
| publication | DarkEcho | 
| artist | Charles Burns | 
| film | Stir of Echoes | 
| television show | The X-Files | 
| television show | Storm of the Century | 
| special award | Dan D'Auria | 
|  1999  | |
| novel | Fog Heart, Thomas Tessier | 
| first novel | (tie) Silk, Caitlín R. Kiernan | 
| first novel | (tie) Dawn Song, Michael Marano | 
| long fiction | “Mr. Clubb and Mr. Cuff”, Peter Straub | 
| short fiction | “Dead Blue”, Lucy Taylor | 
| graphic story/illustrated narrative | Transmetropolitan: Back on the Street, written by Warren Ellis, art by Darick Robertson | 
| collection | Black Butterflies: A Flock on the Dark Side, John Shirley | 
| anthology | Dark Terrors 4, Stephen Jones & David Sutton, eds. | 
| nonfiction | St. James Guide to Horror, Ghost, and Gothic Writers, David Pringle, ed. | 
| publication | Hellnotes | 
| artist | Edward Gorey | 
| film | Gods and Monsters | 
| television show | Buffy the Vampire Slayer | 
|  1998  | |
| Living Legend | Hugh B. Cave | 
| novel | Nazareth Hill, Ramsey Campbell | 
| first novel | Drawn to the Grave, Mary Ann Mitchell | 
| short story | “Cram”, John Shirley | 
| short form | “Coppola's Dracula”, Kim Newman | 
| graphic story/illustrated narrative | Preacher: Proud Americans, Garth Ennis & Steve Dillon, eds. | 
| collection | The Throne of Bones, Brian McNaughton | 
| anthology | Revelations (UK title: Millennium), Douglas E. Winter, ed. | 
| publication | Necrofile | 
| artist | Stephen R. Bissette | 
|  1997  | |
| Living Legend | Edward Bryant | 
| novel | The 37th Mandala, Marc Laidlaw | 
| first novel | Dead Heat, Del Stone, Jr. | 
| short story | “Underbed”, Graham Masterton | 
| short form | “Brimstone and Salt”, S. P. Somtow | 
| graphic story/illustrated narrative | Hellboy: Wake the Devil, Mike Mignola | 
| collection | Conference with the Dead, Terry Lamsley | 
| anthology | Darkside: Horror for the New Millennium, John Pelan, ed. | 
| publication | Cemetery Dance, Richard T. Chizmar | 
| artist | Timothy Bradstreet | 
| film | Scream | 
| special award | Lou Stathis | 
|  1996  | |
| Living Legend | Clive Barker | 
| novel | Resume with Monsters, William Browning Spencer | 
| first novel | The Safety of Unknown Cities, Lucy Taylor | 
| long fiction | The Bars on Satan's Jailhouse, Norman Partridge | 
| short fiction | “Loop”, Douglas E. Winter | 
| graphic story/illustrated narrative | From Hell, Alan Moore & Eddie Campbell | 
| collection | Cages, Ed Gorman | 
| anthology | Best New Horror 6, Stephen Jones, ed. | 
| publication | Deathrealm | 
| artist | J. K. Potter | 
| film | The Lord of Illusions | 
| special award | Cheri Lynn "Tomi" Lewis | 
|  1995  | |
| Living Legend | Harlan Ellison | 
| novel | Anno Dracula, Kim Newman | 
| first novel | Grave Markings, Michael Arnzen | 
| long fiction | “Black Sun”, Douglas E. Winter | 
| short fiction | “The Safety of Unknown Cities”, Lucy Taylor | 
| graphic story/illustrated narrative | Jonah Hex: Two Gun Mojo, Joe R. Lansdale & Tim Truman | 
| collection | Angels & Visitations: A Miscellany, Neil Gaiman | 
| anthology | Love in Vein, Poppy Z. Brite, ed. | 
| publication | Answer Me! | 
| artist | Alan M. Clark | 
| film | Interview with the Vampire |